Ariane Hundt · Blog

Why Cardio Works… Until It Doesn’t

← All articles
Woman sitting on a workout box after exercise

When you first start running again, you come home feeling like yourself in a way you haven’t in months. You’re a little breathless, your cheeks are warm, and by the time you’ve showered, you’ve already decided when you’ll go again. A few weeks in, you’re moving more, your jeans feel looser, and you start to think you’ve finally found something that works.

Then the longer runs begin to follow you into the rest of your day. You finish lunch and find yourself back in the kitchen looking for something else. By Friday, your legs still feel heavy from Wednesday. You skip the walk you’d normally take after dinner because you’ve already done your workout and, frankly, you’d rather sit down. The scale hasn’t moved in three weeks. So you look at your calendar and try to figure out where you can fit in another run.

Before you do, I’d look at what changed in the hours after you started exercising more.

What your workout changes about the rest of your day

The law of metabolic compensation describes a tendency for the body to adjust when you change how much energy you take in or expend. A run can increase your energy expenditure. It can also change how hungry you are at dinner, how much you move later in the day and how much energy you have for tomorrow’s workout. Those responses vary from person to person, which is why two women can follow the same training plan and have very different results. daveasprey.com

In one supervised exercise study, the participants who lost less weight than expected tended to eat more as their appetite increased. The researchers didn’t find a significant drop in resting metabolism or day-to-day activity that explained the result. That matters when you’re trying to figure out what’s happening in your own life. It’s easy to look at a stalled scale and conclude your metabolism has slowed down. It’s more useful to notice that you’re suddenly hungry an hour after lunch and that the dinner that used to satisfy you now leaves you looking for more. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

You can see this during marathon training. A woman might be running more miles than she ever has and find that her weight barely changes. She’s eating more because she’s hungrier, and she needs enough food to recover and run again. If her goal is to finish a marathon, that appetite is useful information. If her goal is fat loss and she’s adding miles solely because she thinks she has to burn more calories, it’s worth asking whether all that extra training is moving her toward the result she wants. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

Why you can feel puffier when you’re training harder

I know how discouraging it is to wake up sore after a hard session and see the scale go up. A new or unusually demanding workout can leave you temporarily holding more water as your muscles recover and replenish glycogen, the carbohydrate they store for fuel. That can make the number on the scale a poor guide to what’s happening with body fat over a few days.

A hard workout is also a stressor. Stress hormones can rise during intense exercise as part of the normal response that helps you meet the demand. A tough session can feel great when you’re sleeping well and eating enough. That same session can leave you wrung out in a week when you’re waking at 3 a.m., working through lunch and squeezing in a class because it’s the only hour you have. I’d pay attention to that difference. Temporary water retention and changes in body fat are different processes, and a puffy morning gives you very little information about whether your approach is working over time.

What I look at before I add another workout

When a woman tells me she’s doing everything right and getting nowhere, I ask her to walk me through a training day. What did she eat before she left the house? How did she feel mid-afternoon? When did the cravings show up? Did she feel ready to train again by the next session? Hunger, energy and cravings tell me a great deal about what the plan is asking of her. Her sleep, soreness and performance help me see whether she’s recovering well enough to benefit from it. daveasprey.com

Sometimes the change is as simple as replacing two punishing classes with shorter strength sessions and going for a walk on the days in between. Sometimes it’s eating a proper lunch so she can finish work without feeling ravenous. And sometimes she loves running, feels good doing it and wants to keep every mile. We can work with that. I want her training to fit her goals and her life well enough that she can keep doing it, including in a week that doesn’t go to plan.

That’s what I teach inside Slim & Strong. You’ll follow structured strength workouts and learn how to adjust your training and nutrition as your energy, appetite and recovery change. Over time, you get better at telling when to challenge yourself, when to give yourself more time to recover and when the thing that would help most is a decent meal. That’s a skill you can keep using long after a programme ends.

Join the Slim & Strong membership

If the pattern you keep running into is around food, pressure or the need to keep pushing even when you’re exhausted, I also explore that in my online private sessions.

Explore private Decode sessions

Ariane Hundt

Ariane HundtMS in Functional/Clinical Nutrition and Psychosomatic Practitioner with more than 25 years of experience. Online sessions for clients in New York City, Los Angeles, across the US, Ireland, the UK, and worldwide.

← Back to all articles