
By the time you sit down for dinner, you’ve already heard three different explanations for why you can’t lose weight. At the gym, someone tells you to lift heavier. On your phone, a woman with a chart says it’s all about calories. Then a friend sends you a video about cortisol that sounds so much like your life you watch it twice.
You can see the sense in all of it. That’s what makes it so confusing. You’ve been to the gym three times this week. You’ve measured out your breakfast, walked at lunch and gone to bed early enough to get eight hours, only to wake at three. Now you’re standing at the kitchen counter after dinner, eating something you weren’t hungry for ten minutes ago. By the time you go upstairs, you’ve decided to be stricter tomorrow.
I’ve spent more than twenty years working with women on nutrition, exercise and weight loss. When a woman tells me she’s tried everything, I believe her. What I want to know is what each of those approaches asked of her, and what happened when she tried to live that way on an ordinary Wednesday.
Why so much of the advice sounds right
A trainer may see that you spend most of your day sitting and could benefit from getting stronger. A dietitian might notice you’re eating so little during the day that you arrive at dinner ravenous. Your doctor may pick up on changes in your sleep, your cycle or your medication that deserve a closer look. Each of them is noticing something that could matter. You’re the one who has to fit their advice into the same day.
Energy balance helps explain changes in body weight over time. It tells you very little about what it takes to get through an afternoon on the lunch you’ve packed, especially if you barely slept and trained hard that morning. You may find yourself hungrier, reaching for more food at dinner or moving less once you get home. A plan can look perfectly reasonable on paper and leave you spending half your day thinking about when you get to eat again.
The same goes for exercise. I love seeing a woman discover what she can lift after years of thinking she has to run herself into the ground. But I also want to know how she feels after she leaves the gym. Is she getting stronger? Does she have enough energy to get through the day? Can she recover before the next session? Those answers help me decide whether to add something to her programme or give her more room to recover.
What happens just before you reach for food?
Sometimes a woman comes to me convinced there must be something wrong with her because she keeps eating when she knows she’s full. I ask her to take me through the evening.
She’s finished dinner. Her husband asks where something is, one of the kids needs help with homework, and there’s an email she’s been thinking about since four. By the time the house goes quiet, she can finally eat something without having to get up halfway through it. She stands at the counter because the thought of getting out a plate feels like one more thing to do. For a few minutes, nobody asks her for anything.
In another woman’s life, that same moment feels entirely different. She’s been alone all evening, and eating gives her something to look forward to. Or she’s been keeping such a close eye on what she eats that the first bite of something she’d ruled out feels like a chance to stop thinking about food for a while.
This is the part I’m interested in. What does the food give you in those few minutes? What would you miss if you simply took it away?
Where I begin
Sometimes we start with lunch. A woman needs more food earlier in the day, and when she starts eating it, the evening feels different. Sometimes we change her training because she’s exhausted and every workout has become another test she has to pass. And sometimes we stay with that moment at the kitchen counter long enough for her to say, often with some surprise, “I think this is the only time of day that’s mine.”
That opens up a very different conversation. What happens when she asks for time before everyone else has had what they need? Who does she worry she’ll disappoint? Can she sit on the sofa at seven with a book, or does she spend the whole time thinking about the dishes? If she grew up believing that being needed was how she earned her place, even a quiet half hour can feel oddly uncomfortable.
My work brings those conversations into the same room as nutrition and training. We can look at what you’re eating, how you’re moving and what happens when you try to make those changes in the life you actually live. Over time, you begin to spot the pattern earlier. You notice you’re hungry while there’s still time to eat lunch. You hear yourself about to say yes and realise you’d rather say no. You can have a difficult evening without spending the next morning figuring out how to make up for it.
If you’ve spent years asking which weight-loss advice you’re supposed to follow, I’d start a little closer to home. Think of a recent day when the plan fell apart. What was happening in the hour before? What did you need by then, and how long had you been putting it off? Your answers tell me more about where to begin than a list of all the diets you’ve tried.
If you’d like to explore that with me, bring one moment you keep finding yourself in. We can start there.