Ariane Hundt · Blog

She Knew Exactly What to Do. So Why Couldn’t She Stop Eating?

← All articles
A chocolate-chip cookie with white chocolate pieces

She Knew Exactly What to Do. So Why Couldn’t She Stop Eating?

Why binge eating is less about the food than the life you need relief from

Jenny stood in the frozen-food aisle having an argument with herself. She knew how the evening would go. She would buy the ice cream, drive home and tell herself she would have a small bowl. Then one bowl would become another. Or she would eat directly from the carton, standing at the kitchen counter, barely tasting it after the first few bites. Part of her was already saying, Don’t buy it. You know what happens when you bring it home. Another part had already made the decision. I don’t care. I’m having it anyway.

Jenny wasn’t confused about nutrition. She had spent years learning what to eat. She exercised consistently, understood calories and had tried therapy, meal plans, portion-controlled foods and every practical strategy she could find. She had bought individually wrapped ice cream containers because one serving was supposed to make moderation easier. But one always became three. She could watch herself doing it and still feel unable to stop. That was the part she couldn’t understand. Why would an intelligent, capable woman repeatedly act against what she said she wanted? The answer wasn’t that she needed more discipline. It was that the binge was doing far more for her than she realized.

The binge began long before the ice cream

When Jenny was young, food came with rules, observation and commentary. There were foods she wasn’t supposed to eat. Treats belonged to other people in the family. She began to associate eating with being watched, judged and controlled. Then she discovered what happened when nobody was home. She could open the fridge and eat whatever she wanted. She could have the snacks she wasn’t normally allowed. When she was in college, her kitchen was full of foods she never had at home. For a little while, nobody could comment. Nobody could tell her what was enough. Nobody could make her feel wrong. She could do whatever she wanted. The food tasted good, but that wasn’t the whole reward. The real relief was freedom.

Why restriction made her want more

People often respond to binge eating with more rules. Don’t keep trigger foods in the house. Buy individual portions. Replace the ice cream with yogurt. Brush your teeth after dinner. Distract yourself until the craving passes. Some of those strategies can interrupt a binge temporarily. But they don’t change the emotional meaning of the food. For Jenny, another rule didn’t feel helpful. It felt like the same old message she had received as a child: You cannot be trusted. You are not allowed to have what you want. Someone else knows what is best for you. So the binge became an act of rebellion. The voice saying, I don’t care, I’m eating it anyway, wasn’t the voice of a woman who had given up on herself. It was a younger part of her fighting to reclaim some power. She wasn’t only eating the ice cream. She was saying no to control. She was taking something nobody could withhold. She was finally getting to decide.

The capable woman who was exhausted from holding everything together

On the outside, Jenny looked extraordinarily capable. She had built a successful career. She was the person who anticipated problems, remembered the details and made sure things got done. She cared for family members, helped before anyone asked and felt responsible for keeping life running smoothly. But this competence had not begun as a simple personality trait. As a child, Jenny learned to monitor the emotional weather around her. If an adult was unhappy, irritated or disappointed, the atmosphere could change quickly. A small mistake could become evidence that she had failed. Forgetting her chores or simply wanting to continue reading instead of doing what someone else expected could lead to anger. She learned to brace, scan the room and do everything properly so nobody would become upset. And she carried that strategy into adulthood. Even when nobody was demanding perfection from her, her body still prepared for the possibility that something might go wrong. Her shoulders tightened. Her stomach contracted. Her mind ran through lists, checking what still needed to be handled. She had become responsible for everyone else’s needs and emotions while becoming almost invisible to herself. By the end of the day, the ice cream was not just dessert. It was the moment she could stop being responsible.

The binge gave her what she didn’t know how to ask for

Yes, the ice cream soothed her. For Jenny, its softness and sweetness carried an association with nurturing. The comfort of being cared for, reassured and allowed to need something. It offered a version of the maternal tenderness she had longed for but had rarely experienced in the way she needed. But the binge was not only about mothering or emotional comfort.

It gave her several things at once:

  • Relief: For a few minutes, she could stop anticipating, planning and holding everything together.
  • Agency: Nobody else could decide how much she was allowed to have.
  • Rebellion: She could break the rules that had made her feel controlled and wrong.
  • Privacy: Eating alone meant nobody was watching, comparing or judging her.
  • Reward: After giving her energy to everyone else, the food felt like the one thing that was just for her.
  • Numbing: It quieted emotions she had never learned how to feel safely.
  • Connection: In the absence of someone comforting her, the food created a temporary sense that she was not entirely alone.

This is why one small serving often wasn’t enough. She wasn’t trying to satisfy physical hunger. She was trying to fill years of emotional deprivation, release a day’s worth of pressure and recover a sense of freedom, all through a carton of ice cream. No food can carry that much responsibility.

Why understanding the pattern hadn’t changed it

Jenny had spoken about her childhood before. She understood that her family dynamics had affected her. She knew she ate when she was anxious or lonely. But insight alone had not stopped the binge. Knowing why you do something is not always the same as changing the internal story that keeps creating it. Jenny could explain everyone else’s behavior beautifully. She could see that the adults around her had their own pain. She could understand why they were stressed, resentful or emotionally unavailable. What she had rarely done was remain with her own experience long enough to feel it. The moment anger or sadness surfaced, she moved quickly into compassion for everyone else. She explained them, forgave them and made their behavior understandable. It looked emotionally mature, but it was also the same pattern she had lived for decades: Their feelings come first. Mine can wait. The work was to let the younger Jenny finally say what she had never been able to say: Stop making me responsible for your feelings. I am allowed to want what I want. I am allowed to be joyful. Your resentment is not my fault. I do not have to become someone else to be safe.

You cannot remove a coping mechanism without replacing what it provides

If we had focused only on removing the ice cream, Jenny would have been left with the same pressure, loneliness, resentment and exhaustion, and no reliable way to meet those feelings. Eventually, another behaviour would have stepped in. That is why my work does not begin by asking, “How do we make you stop eating this?” We begin with different questions: What is happening just before you reach for it? What are you feeling in your body? What does the food allow you to feel… or help you avoid feeling? What do you actually need in that moment?

For Jenny, the answer might be rest. It might be comfort, freedom, play, help, reassurance or the right to disappoint someone without making their reaction mean she has failed. Sometimes the new response is small. She pauses before automatically agreeing to help. She asks herself how she wants to respond. She allows another person to be unhappy without rushing to fix it. She plans a meal around her own needs instead of treating herself as an afterthought. She calls a friend and admits that she is struggling. She wraps herself in a blanket and lets herself cry. She puts on music and walks until she feels that light, joyful part of herself return. She may still eat the ice cream. But now it is no longer the only place she can find relief.

The binge is not proof that you are broken

A binge can look irrational from the outside. You know you will feel uncomfortable afterward. You know the guilt that follows. You may even hear yourself saying, Why am I doing this again? But when you understand what the behaviour has been providing, it begins to make sense. The binge may be the only place you stop being good. The only moment nobody needs anything from you. The only reward you allow yourself. The only way you know how to soften the loneliness. The only time the part of you that has felt controlled gets to say, No. This is mine. You do not change that pattern by fighting yourself harder. You change it by resolving the story that made the binge necessary—and learning to give yourself, in real and lasting ways, what you have been asking food to provide. That is where freedom begins.

Jenny is a pseudonym, and identifying details have been changed to protect client confidentiality. Ready to understand what your eating pattern is really trying to do for you?

In my private Decode sessions, we identify the emotional story beneath the pattern, process what has remained unresolved and create a different way of responding—so food no longer has to carry the weight of everything you have been holding.

LEARN MORE ABOUT PRIVATE DECODE SESSIONS

Ariane HundtMS in Functional/Clinical Nutrition and Psychosomatic Practitioner with more than 25 years of experience. Online sessions for clients in New York City, Los Angeles, across the US, Ireland, the UK, and worldwide.

← Back to all articles